Mason Island, CT Listings Local Resources Dining Shopping Leisure Highest Rated Dining The Shipwright's Daughter $$ 324 reviews Seafood, New American, Breakfast & Brunch (860) 536-7605 20 E Main StMystic, CT 06355 The Mariner $$ 529 reviews Seafood, New American, Bars (860) 536-5200 21 W Main StMystic, CT 06355 Engine Room $$ 1485 reviews Southern, New American, Comfort Food (860) 415-8117 14 Holmes StMystic, CT 06355 Oyster Club $$$ 926 reviews New American, Seafood (860) 415-9266 13 Water StMystic, CT 06355 Red 36 $$ 1007 reviews Seafood, Bars, American (860) 536-3604 2 Washington StMystic, CT 06355 Via Emilia $$$ 190 reviews Italian (860) 415-4840 24 W Main StMystic, CT 06355 Pop Over Eatery $$ 50 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Sandwiches, Vegan (860) 245-5139 24 E Main StMystic, CT 06355 S&P Oyster Restaurant and Bar $$$ 1218 reviews Seafood, Desserts, Cocktail Bars (860) 536-2674 1 Holmes StMystic, CT 06355 Andiamo $ 113 reviews Bars, Italian (860) 415-1151 247 Greenmanville AveMystic, CT 06355 Noble Smokehouse $ 179 reviews Barbeque, Smokehouse (860) 415-9564 4 Roosevelt AveMystic, CT 06355 The Captain Daniel Packer Inne $$ 710 reviews American, Seafood, Gastropubs (860) 536-3555 32 Water StMystic, CT 06355 Rio Salado $$ 280 reviews Mexican (860) 245-5152 8 Coogan BlvdMystic, CT 06355 Whitecrest Eatery $$ 90 reviews New American, American (860) 980-0984 22 Bayview AveSte 14 The Port of Call $ 71 reviews Lounges, Cocktail Bars, Tapas/Small Plates 15 Water StMystic, CT 06355 Nana’s Mystic $$ 121 reviews Bakeries, Coffee & Tea, Pizza (860) 980-3375 32 Williams AveMystic, CT 06355 Trattoria Amalfi $ 90 reviews Italian (860) 440-6770 27 Coogan BlvdSte 22B Milestone - Mystic $ 21 reviews Bars, Chicken Wings, Pizza (860) 980-8787 12 Water StMystic, CT 06355 Dog Watch Cafe $$ 565 reviews American, Seafood, Chicken Wings (860) 415-4510 194 Water StStonington, CT 06378 The Fisherman at Long Point $$$ 303 reviews Seafood, American (860) 536-1111 937 Groton Long Point RdGroton Long Point, CT 06340 Bravo Bravo $$$ 356 reviews Italian, American (860) 536-3228 19 E Main StMystic, CT 06355 Friar Tuck's Tavern $$ 195 reviews Irish, American, Sports Bars (860) 572-6069 12 Water StMystic, CT 06355 Toast + Tonic Creative Kitchen $ 33 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Salad, Sandwiches (860) 536-6343 27 Coogan BlvdBldg 16 Kitchen Little $$ 485 reviews Breakfast & Brunch, Seafood (860) 536-2122 36 Quarry RdMystic, CT 06355 Taquerio $$ 104 reviews Tacos (860) 245-4420 30 Broadway AveMystic, CT 06355 Mystic Oysters $ 12 reviews Seafood, Soup 15 Holmes StMystic, CT 06355